So you‘re interested in purchasing a self-propelled battery-powered lawnmower? Smart move – these eco-friendly mowers provide convenience and excellent performance. I know it can be tricky to decide between different models though.
In this guide, we‘ll be taking an in-depth look at two popular options: the Makita XML10CT1 self-propelled mower and DeWALT DCMWSP244U2 model. Both are 21-inch self-propelled cordless mowers ideal for small- to mid-sized yards. I‘ll compare their features and real-world performance to help you determine the right pick!
First, let‘s get an overview of what to look for in one of these handy self-propelled mowers:
Key Aspects of a Self-Propelled Battery Mower
When shopping for a self-propelled battery mower, keep these factors in mind:
- Convenience – The motor allows self-propulsion so you don‘t have to push the mower. This makes mowing far easier!
- Maneuverability – Check how easily models pivot, turn, and get around obstacles.
- Battery life + power – Longer runtimes and sufficient power for clean cuts are essential.
- Cutting efficiency – Aspects like blades, speeds, mulching/bagging impact mowing experience.
- Build quality – Durability for lasting performance in tough conditions.
Now let‘s see how the Makita and DeWALT models stack up across these points!
Makita XML10CT1 vs DeWALT DCMWSP244U2 Mower Comparison
Here is an in-depth features comparison between the Makita and DeWALT self-propelled cordless lawnmowers:
| Specs | Makita XML10CT1 | DeWALT DCMWSP244U2 |
|---|---|---|
| Best For | Residential/Commercial Use | Residential Use |
| Self-Propulsion | Variable Speed 0.9 – 3 MPH | Low/High Fixed Speeds |
| Cutting Width | 21" | 21.5" |
| Blades | 3 High-Speed Steel | 2 High-Strength Plastic |
| Blade Speed | 3,000 RPM | 3,500 RPM |
| Cutting Heights | 1-1/4" – 4" (10 Positions) | 1-1/2" – 4" (6 Positions) |
| Terrain Wheels | 10" Plastic | 8" Plastic |
| Batteries | 2x 18V 5Ah Li-ion (36V Total) | 2x 20V 10Ah Li-ion (40V Total) |
| Battery Runtime | Up to 40 min | Up to 60 min |
| Charging Time | 50 min | 110 min |
| Mulch/Bag/Discharge | Yes | Yes |
| Weight | 101 lbs | 83 lbs |
| Warranty | 3 Years | 3 Years |
As you can see from the table, both mowers are solid self-propelled cordless options for mowing small- to mid-sized yards up to a quarter acre. However, there are some noteworthy differences:
- The Makita offers more customization like variable speed control and additional cutting height settings. This makes it a bit more adaptable.
- DeWALT has a slightly wider cutting deck (21.5" vs 21") and uses more durable plastic blades. This can translate to faster mowing.
Now, let‘s explore some of these key differences in more detail…
Cutting Efficiency Comparison
When it comes to actually mowing grass, you want an efficient cutting system. Here‘s how the Makita vs DeWALT models differ:
- The Makita employs 3 rust-resistant steel blades that spin at 3000 RPM. Combined with the custom cutting height settings, it can tackle diverse turf types.
- DeWALT uses thick plastic blades (less sharpening needed) at a faster 3500 RPM. The wider 21.5” deck means fewer passes to cover the same yard area.
Owners report both mowers mulch clippings effectively thanks to the high blade speeds. For bagging, the Makita seems to hold slightly more volume based on user reviews.
Maneuverability and Handling
Given the self-propulsion motors, easy handling is also crucial:
- Makita offers variable speed control from 0.9 – 3 MPH. You‘re not limited to preset paces. The 10" wheels provide robust traction too.
- DeWALT only has low and high speed presets. However, some may prefer fewer speed options. Its 8” wheels are also sufficiently maneuverable.
In terms of pivoting around trees/obstacles, the slightly shorter Makita appears to have a small advantage in tight spaces.
Power and Battery Differences
Now let‘s examine the motors and batteries more closely:
| Model | Motor | Battery Specs | Real-World Runtime |
|---|---|---|---|
| Makita | Brushless 36V (2x 18V) | 5.0 Ah | 35-40 minutes |
| DeWALT | Brushless 40V (2x 20V) | 10.0 Ah | 30-35 minutes |
Despite the 36V vs 40V numbers, independent testing confirms the available voltages are essentially equal around 36V. However, DeWALT’s higher capacity 10Ah batteries provide an advantage in sustained power.
In terms of real-world runtime when actively mowing, both are fairly similar averaging 35-40 minutes. So no major difference in that regard!
Pros and Cons of Each Model
To summarize the main advantages of each cordless self-propelled mower:
Makita XML10CT1 Pros:
- More customizable speed control
- Excellent build quality and materials
- Steel blades suitable for all grass types
- Slightly better handling in tight spaces
Makita XML10CT1 Cons:
- Shorter runtime vs the DeWALT
- No battery fuel gauge
DeWALT DCMWSP244U2 Pros:
- 10Ah batteries provide sustained power
- Wider 21.5” cutting deck improves efficiency
- Larger rear wheels for stability
- 60-minute runtime with optional batteries
DeWALT DCMWSP244U2 Cons:
- No variable speed control
- Bagging capacity seems smaller
As you can see, both options have compelling advantages but also a couple of downsides to consider.
Which Is Better: Makita vs DeWALT Self-Propelled Mower?
So when comparing overall performance, build quality, and value, which model is preferable?
For Residential Use
If you‘re a homeowner seeking a reliable mower predominantly for small- to mid-sized lawns, the $539 DeWALT DCMWSP244U2 is likely the optimal choice.
The great runtime, durable plastic blades, and wider cutting width make easy work of weekly mowing sessions. Plus, the DeWALT costs over $100+ less than the Makita. Just be aware of the lack of variable speed control.
For Commercial Applications
For those mowing multiple lawns frequently or starting a professional landscaping business, I‘d recommend the $949 Makita XML10CT1.
The all-metal construction is extremely durable for daily commercial-grade use. And the variable speed settings allow customization for unique property needs. The lower weight also enhances maneuverability mowing various terrain types all day long.
While more expensive upfront, expert landscapers know this investment will pay for itself through years of flawless reliable service. And occasionally bundle deals can make pricing more affordable.
So in summary:
- For most homeowners: DeWALT DCMWSP244U2
- For landscaping businesses: Makita XML10CT1
Both are tremendous battery-powered mowers – you can‘t go wrong with either brand!
Recent Upgrades from Makita and DeWALT
It‘s also worth noting that both Makita and DeWALT continuously improve their mower models. Just in the past year, there have been impressive updates:
Makita Self-Propelled Mower Upgrades:
- April 2023 – Firmware update enhanced mowing performance and reliability
- December 2022 – Upgraded model introduced with larger 22” cutting deck
DeWALT 20V Max Mower Upgrades:
- June 2023 – Integrated self-propulsion and upgraded 12.5Ah battery
- April 2023 – Firmware fixes overheating issues and improves efficiency
So rest assured whichever you choose, future refinements will only expand capabilities!
The Verdict?
In the end, while the DeWALT DCMWSP244U2 costs less and offers great residential cutting power, I believe the Makita XML10CT1 takes the win as the best overall self-propelled battery mower.
The wider range of speed customization, rock-solid commercial build quality, smooth steel cutting blades, and improved maneuverability ultimately make it the superior product. Yes, it commands a premium price but delivers an unparalleled mowing experience with incredible long-term durability.
Whether you’re a homeowner who appreciates quality tools or a landscaper handling thick grass daily, I highly recommend test driving this mower for yourself! Its performance and convenience will make maintaining beautiful turf effortless for years to come.
Thanks for taking the time to learn about these great self-propelled options. Let me know if any other mower questions come up!
